
August 9, 2011
Rev. Edward Dougherty, M.M.
Superior General of Maryknoll Brothers and Fathers
P.O. Box 305
Maryknoll, NY 10545-0305
Dear Fr. Dougherty and the members of the Maryknoll Council,
The Board and members of CORPUS reaffirm our support of Fr. Roy Bourgeois regarding women’s ordination. How disappointing that Maryknoll has sent him the second canonical warning. Over its history, Maryknoll has been known for its courage and prophetic voice in spreading and proclaiming the gospel of Jesus. It seems clear that you and Maryknoll have lost your way. You have sent men and women throughout the world as witnesses of the gospel. Now you are unwilling to support the prophetic voice of one of your own brothers.
The papal claim to infallibility in saying that women are not fit to be ordained is tenuous at best. For any doctrine to be infallible, it must be accepted by the “sensus fidelium.” If you look at the stance of Catholics around the world, it is by no means universally accepted by the baptized. In fact, more and more people are rejecting the papal assertion. It is clearly the lesson of history that doctrines change and develop. One obvious example is the now universal rejection of slavery, despite a whole scriptural history that accepted it as a norm in society. This is true even in the Pauline epistles. Slavery is now condemned despite a long held “tradition” of accepting it as a societal norm.
Our present pope, Benedict XVI, as a theologian to Vatican II, wrote clearly and forcefully about the primacy of conscience. Fr. Roy, who has been a faithful servant of the Church and Maryknoll, is obliged by his conscience to continue speaking out about sexism and women’s ordination. What a contradiction that Maryknoll and the Vatican condemn him for doing so. CORPUS stands with Fr. Roy and urges Maryknoll to do likewise.
With prayers,
John and Roberta Hydar
Secretary